|
THE PASSION OF THE
CHRIST
|
|
Wow! Amazing! This is a rather historic Ash Wednesday. This film, “The
Passion of Christ” is being shown all across the country in over 4000 theaters. |
I can’t do a review of the film. It is most unlikely I will ever see it.
I’m just not into movies. They say that a movie is never as good as the
book. And I’ve read the book many times. Of course. if you don’t read books...
My illiteracy is lack of knowledge of films. |
In fact, until this last week the last movie I saw was a black arid white
silent Charlie Chaplin film. I don’t want to spoil the memory. The movie
I sew last week was in a small theater on a small screen in which one of
my lovely granddaughters played an important part. How could I not go?
So you see, I’m not the best place to look for a review. As it turns out
there will probably be more reviews of this film than of anything recent.
If you care, you are in luck. |
But that doesn’t mean I don’t have an opinion. |
I have read some reviews and listened to some who actually saw the film.
Since I am writing this from our cabin on Puget Sound, I am within radio
reach of KlRO in Seattle where a guy named Dave Ross has a morning talk
show. He’s fairly informed and wide thinking individual who happens to
be an active Catholic. This gives him a bit more insight into the film
than you might expect from a non-Catholic. |
His view of the film was that while graphic blood and gore of the crucifixion
scenes is not pleasing, it is not surprising to one who has been raised
to think about that dying during every Sunday Mass. His take is that the
flashbacks away from the brutality of the last hours of Christ’ life carry
the real message about Jesus. Like, why is he being treated this way? And
what was he really like? |
Apparently the flashback scenes are the ones in which Jesus takes stands
of non-violence, non-resistance, non-judgement, unqualified forgiveness
of enemies and persecutors arid claiming oneness with God. He stood against
the rigidity of his own religious tradition and was seen as a threat by
the Roman occupation forces. He practiced non-flinching love toward all
people. |
So, what does all that bloody movie get us? Dave Ross wonders whether it
would make Christians go out and forgive their enemies, give living wages
to their employees, fight for health care for the poor, pay for education
of children, and so on. He wondered whether it would inspire Christians
to act like—can you imagine—Christians? |
It is an unusual day when evangelical and fundamentalist Christians will
celebrate a Catholic film. Some were surprised that the Catholics could
be so true to the Bible. I suppose that most Protestants don’t quite get
the fact that it was the Catholics that chose the books of the Bible. These
books carried the version of “the gospel” that the church had decided to
accept. Protestants inherited the Catholic Bible. Why shouldn’t the Catholic
film sound “true to the Bible? |
Of course “true to the Bible” does not mean that it is history. The Gospel
writers were like filmmakers, each imagining their own story. |
Those who want to dig deeper into this whole subject, especially into the
historicity of the Whole Passion Story, might wish to read Raymond Brown’s
“The Death of the Messiah.” As a Catholic scholar he couldn’t quite come
right out and say that the Gospel Passion story was more story than history.
He did say that the Passion story is more theology than history. |
The talk-show discussion has to do with the degree of bloody horror. Do
we need it? Maybe the answer is “yes.” Those who remember the nightly news
reports from the Vietnam War will remember graphic film footage of carnage
and death. It took those pictures to bring our nation to say “enough.”
Jesus is not the only human to have suffered the silence of God. |
The spin put on the film by different people will be interesting to follow.
I’m more interested in the spin-out—whether some people might get a better
Idea of what it means to be “Christian.” I would like to hear Christians
discussing whether our present national “Christian leadership’ thinks,
talks or behaves anything like Jesus who was crucified, or more like the
Roman crucifiers? Heresy, of course, but just a thought. Remember, I didn’t
see the movie. I just read the book. Have a happy Lent.
— Art Morgan,
Ash Wednesday, 2004
|
|