|
ARE YOU AN EPISCOPALIAN
?
|
|
Among the last things I hope for while at leisure in Baja is a theological
discussion. In fact, it’s one of the last things I would expect among of
group of guys from Wyoming who were here to fish for Marlin. |
Somehow word was out that I was “retired clergy.” It’s a small place and
perhaps someone had ratted on me. I was just making small talk while walking
by where these fellows were looking out over the bay and consuming a second
pitcher of Margarita’s. It was not yet lunchtime. One of the men asked,
“Are you an Episcopalian?” |
Interesting question to be asking a stranger. But Margarita’s encourage
familiarity. |
“No, I don’t happen to be Episcopalian, but I have respect for some
of their scholars.” |
On further inquiry I found that the questioner was a practicing Episcopalian.
You realize, of course, that there are practicing and non-practicing varieties
in all religions. I have usually known Episcopalians of the non-practicing
kind. |
They invited me to sit down and pushed a Margarita in my direction. |
I tried to say something “Episcopalian.” Like, “Some of my best friends
are Episcopalian.” I did better than that. I said, “Some of my favorite
scholars are Episcopalian.” |
Their interest, whetted as I said by those Margarita’s, encouraged me on.
“Are you familiar with John Robinson’s ‘Honest to God,’ and Bishop Spong’s
’Why Christianity Must Change or Die,’ and Marcus Borg’s books like, ’Meeting
Jesus Again for the First Time,’ and ‘The God We Never Knew,’ and ‘Reading
the Bible Again for the First Time?’” |
Eyes sort of blurred over. The Margarita’s I guessed. |
“The names sound familiar, but we don’t hear much about them in our
church.” |
I supposed not. Most clergy don’t have time to discuss such books. Besides,
in most parishes, people don’t want to be upset by such thinking. I expected
that to be the end of the conversation. But the participating Episcopalian
wanted me to say more. |
“You don’t want to hear what these writers are saying,” I said. |
He pushed me until I took a deep breath and simply described the long known
scholarly conclusions about the origin of biblical story and the turning
of myth into history, most notably for Christians, the creation of the
Christian story rooted in ancient myth. “We tend to debate whether it
is ‘true,’ when the real question is ‘what does it mean?’” I even reported
the current debate among Reformed, Conservative and Orthodox Jews about
whether the Abraham story and the stories of Moses are historical. |
The Episcopalian sat up and offered me more Margarita that I refused. He
said, “That’s what I’ve always really thought…that a lot of this stuff
is story with more to it than whether it happened.” |
“Wow,” I thought, wondering how many other Episcopalians were as
thoughtful. |
I told him that he would appreciate the companionship of his fellow Episcopalians
like Robinson, Spong and Borg. I doubt that he’ll remember after the Margarita’s
wear off. |
He went on to tell me that he was an Episcopalian for the liturgy. “I
like the ceremony and the Communion. I hate the music. Episcopalians can’t
sing,” he said. No matter, he still attended. |
“So,” I asked, “what made you think I might be an Episcopalian?” |
“Well, frankly, we saw you with a drink in your hand and decided you
must be an Episcopalian. Our clergy are not straight-laced and enjoy a
drink once in a while. We can have a drink and not feel like hypocrites.” |
I wasn’t sure whether that was a compliment or not. Most clergy I know
these days at least drink some wine. These guys should know that there
are other differences between denominations and Episcopalians. And they
should know that informed biblical scholarship is more a matter of study
and thought than of denominational connection. |
I forgot to mention to them that my blue sheet list has a number of Episcopalians,
some former clergy of my own denomination, and even some retired Episcopal
bishops. I believe them to have distinguished and distinguishing characteristics
beyond appreciation of spirits! I am honored to be mistaken for one of
them.
— Art Morgan,
Baja California Del Sur, Mexico, 2002
|