CONVERSATION IN A TASTING ROOM
|
|
I had just spent the better part of a day “racking” wine. Actually, I was
helping the winemaker, Rob, move wine from the fermentation tanks to barrels.
Not a hard job, really. Low tech. |
Anyway, I went to the tasting room to ask a question about finishing up.
There was a fellow who was doing some wine tasting. Somehow Rob, the winemaker,
got the wine taster going on his understanding of what Osama bin Laden
is all about. |
“Its all about heresy.” |
Excuse me? I thought. Theology is my business. |
Somehow or another the wine taster had done some study of early Christian
theology and Christian history. He seemed determined to report his
knowledge. |
“Religion has to protect itself from heretics.” |
He began to cite all sorts of historic councils in which heresy was voted
down and truth was established in creeds. This led to inquisitions and
holy wars and martyrs and efforts to control what people did and thought
about religious faith. |
I attempted one brief interruption to remind him that the Old Testament
is full of wonderful stories of bloodshed in which the enemies of the Lord
are vanquished. He looked at me in such a way as to make me decide to keep
such heretical ideas to myself. |
“When Mohammedanism began to spread in the 600’s, its intent was to purge
the world of the heresies in Christianity and Judaism.” He mentioned the
Trinity and Virgin Birth and Resurrection as examples of heresies. I didn't
mention that many Christian scholars agree with the Koran on those issues. |
“Their goal is to purge the world of all infidels. It is their duty to
protect their idea of true religion.” |
Again I could agree that almost every one of the 2,000 or more denominations
has some notion that it possesses a unique corner of the truth that needs
to be proclaimed and protected. |
I suspect he was talking about the most radical of Islamic fundamentalists.
Most people aren't that worried about infidels. Some of us have wine to
rack, or something more pressing. |
I forget where the conversation ended up. I think the point was that the
defense by religions against infidels of other beliefs is the norm. Osama
bin Laden is apparently doing what religious zealots do. He hopes to unite
the Arab world in a sort of Muslim spiritual revival of a conservative
form of the Islamic faith. History suggests that such zealots need watching. |
My mind was wandering. I think I still had some barrels to fill. I was
hooked on the word “infidel.” We Americans are accused of being “infidels.” |
“Am I an infidel?” I asked myself. |
Let's get real here. We're all infidels of some
sort. There is an infidelity of belief and practice of religion in all
of us. In fact, I would think it mandatory for any thinking person to be
a doubter and non-practitioner of most orthodox religious groups. I would
think it mandatory for people claiming Christian connections to admit to
unfaithfulness to the call of Christ to have compassion for the poor and
fatherless and strangers in our midst. |
I thought of the file of newspaper articles in which my own country has
unilaterally excused itself from participation in long-standing international
treaties and agreements. How could I not wonder about my country's world-leading
distribution of armaments and munitions to any nation that will buy? Or
about our history of actually training and funding terrorist revolutionaries
(including Osama bin Laden) when it suits “national interest?” The claim
to be a “Christian nation” is questioned when we behave like infidels.
To realize that the Christian churches are silent on these matters leads
me to conclude that we have a certain infidelity to the spirit of religion,
if not to its formulations of faith. |
As an admitted infidel I find myself in a country of infidels being targeted
by another infidel who despairs of converting us. So infidels on two sides
revert to historic means of dealing with those of contrary belief. |
The guy in the tasting room is probably a cynic. And he is probably right.
Religion tends to think that an infidel is one that belongs to a different
religion, race or nation. It is more interested in defending its
dominance than in performing its teachings toward fellow humans. It declares
war to the death in the name of God. Death to the infidels. Which
infidels? I need to get back to work.
— Art Morgan,
November 2001
|